Erin Hill, Michigan State University, Department of Plant, Soil and Microbial Sciences – May 20, 2021
Work continues on new herbicide resistance cases in waterhemp and fall panicum.
In 2020, 19 samples were submitted for herbicide resistance screening to MSU Plant & Pest Diagnostics. The majority of these samples were sponsored by the Michigan Soybean Committee and the Michigan Vegetable Council in partnership with MSU weeds specialist Sushila Chaudhari (i.e., nine and six respectively). The Michigan Soybean Committee covers screening for select weed species growing in soybean rotations (e.g., pigweeds, ragweeds, marestail/horseweed and common lambsquarters) and the Michigan Vegetable Council covers any suspected resistant weed found in vegetable rotations.
From these 15 samples, 11 were confirmed to have some type of herbicide resistance. Two of these cases had not previously been confirmed in the counties in which they were sampled. ALS-resistance (Group 2) in common lambsquarters was documented for the first time in Tuscola County and resistance to the photosystem II inhibiting herbicides (Group 5) in Powell amaranth was documented in Mason County.
One unique case of three-way resistance to glyphosate (Group 9), ALS- and PPO-inhibiting (Group 14) herbicides in waterhemp was documented from Ottawa County. This is the first case of multiple-resistance to three herbicide modes of action in waterhemp submitted to MSU Plant & Pest Diagnostics, therefore further bioassay testing to confirm these initial results in on going. MSU weeds specialist Christy Sprague reported a prior case of similar resistance in waterhemp in 2019 in Isabella County that was confirmed via molecular screening.
As a side note, the option of in-season molecular screening for select weed-resistance combinations will be coming to MSU Plant & Pest Diagnostics through collaboration with MSU weed geneticist Eric Patterson in the coming seasons; stay tuned for more information.
As the number submissions on well-characterized resistant weeds has tapered in the past several years, we have seen an increase in unique resistance inquiries. Common cocklebur, annual ryegrass and fall panicum were all new species submitted for screening in 2020. While no resistance was found in the common cocklebur sample, one of the annual ryegrass samples was confirmed to be resistant to glyphosate in St. Joseph County. Worldwide, annual ryegrass (also known as Italian ryegrass) and its relatives, perennial ryegrass and rigid ryegrass, are some of the most frequently encountered herbicide-resistant weeds, with glyphosate resistance first reported in annual ryegrass in Chile in 2003 (see “Glyphosate-resistant Lolium multiflorum in Chilean orchards” by A. Perez and Marcelo Kogan for more information).
The fall panicum sample from Clinton County showed resistance to the ALS inhibiting herbicide thiencarbazone-methyl (a component of the herbicide Capreno®). This would be the first case of resistance to a Group 2 herbicide in fall panicum worldwide; therefore, additional testing is underway to confirm these preliminary results. These additional tests include a repeated screen and a dose response experiment to determine the level of resistance. As with many of our samples, the seed supplies from this sample and the previously mentioned waterhemp sample were limited, therefore seed increases must be done in the greenhouse before the additional screening can take place.
Herbicide resistance testing will again be available in the fall of 2021, with all submissions due by mid-November. Support from the Michigan Soybean Committee and Michigan Vegetable Council is expected to continue for this season. Information on these supported programs, fees for other types of samples, and the submission process can be found on the MSU Plant & Pest Diagnostics website or in the back of the 2021 Weed Control Guide for Field Crops (E-434).
Information and photos showing how to collect seeds for the bioassays is available in “Tips for collecting weed seeds: Ensure your resistance sample gets tested.” If you have any questions regarding the 2020 results or future sample submissions, please contact Erin Hill ([email protected]) for more information.
Thank you to Christy Sprague for reviewing this article.
New county locations and/or incidents of resistance confirmed from 2020
*G# refers to the herbicide site of action group
- Glyphosate-resistant (G9): St. Joseph County
- ALS-resistant (G2): Tuscola County
- Multiple resistant (ALS-G2 + glyphosate-G9 + PPO-G14): Ottawa County
- ALS-resistant (G2): Clinton County (still being confirmed)
- PSII-resistant (G5): Mason County
This article was published by Michigan State University Extension. For more information, visit https://extension.msu.edu. To have a digest of information delivered straight to your email inbox, visit https://extension.msu.edu/newsletters. To contact an expert in your area, visit https://extension.msu.edu/experts, or call 888-MSUE4MI (888-678-3464).